Milani’s Shadow Eyez pencil in Charming Black review

Posted on Saturday, at bought • 429 views

  • Manufacturer: Milani Cosmetics
  • Availability: part of the limited edition Shadow Eyez Holiday Romance collection; available from drugstores
  • Color Range: black with silver sparkle
  • Cost/Amount: USD$6.00 for .1 ounces / 2.83 grams
  • Would you purchase again: yes
Milani’s Shadow Eyez pencil in Charming Black

I loved this pencil! This and Midnight Romance were my two favorites from this collection. I did find a few spare Midnight Romance pencils to purchase on Ebay; but not a one of Charming Black. Which makes me kind of sad. While Sephora has a Black Glitter pencil, it isn't as deep and creamy a black, it doesn't apply as smoothly, and it doesn't last as long as Charming Black. I really hope that Milani brings this color back again, even if it's only for another LE run, because it is AMAZING.

Photos that show how the product actually performs...! See how I create my swatches

A montage of three images: top left, close-up of the eyeliner tube or pencil barrel; top right, the eyeliner applied over bare skin, to better show the shade and properties; and below, the eyeliner applied on the eyelid at the lash line.

Like this entry? Check these out:


or look at other entries tagged with black, Brand: Milani Cosmetics, discontinued, eye pencil, eyeliner, limited edition, liner pencil, neutral, sparkle

Comments