Notoriously Morbid’s Slay Me collection review and swatches

Posted on Tuesday, at bought • 83 views

  • Manufacturer: Notoriously Morbid
  • Availability: part of the regular line
  • Contains: 51 eye colors
  • Cost/Amount: USD$3.00 for 1.25 grams, 6.00 for 2.5 grams, 8.00 for 5.0 grams
  • Would you purchase again: yes, some of the colors
All of the entries for the year 2020 were completed before March 2020. Most items were bought in, or before, 2019. And so, despite the pandemic where buying makeup is definitely a lower priority, I'm still publishing these posts.
Notoriously Morbid’s Slay Me collection

Fifty-one matte eyeshadows named after Buffy the Vampire Slayer. I haven’t bought every matte in this collection, and with 51 colors I likely won’t buy them all. There’s a fairly decent variety of shades, and both the lighter and darker ends of the spectrum are present. Several of the pink-reds are a bit more similar than the vendor photos suggest, though; and I noticed a handful of shades that had an odd whitish layer when swatched wet. My personal favorites are Neutered, Good Little Girl Routine, and Burn All The Witches.

Photos that show how the product actually performs...! See how I create my swatches

Four eyeshadows swatched: 5 by 5, Best Bunch of Months, Four eyeshadows, swatched: Curds and Whey, Cute Weak and Kitteny, Doll's Eye, and Good Little Girl Routine. Four eyeshadows, swatched: I Call It Mr. Pointy, Logic Boy, Lost in LA, and Mr. Library. Four eyeshadows, swatched: Neutered, Quiet Storm, and Won't Be Heard.

Like this entry? Check these out:

or look at other entries tagged with Brand: Notoriously Morbid, collection