CoverGirl’s Peacock Flare Waterproof Mascara
This gave me fairly good definition and a nice bit of length, but it was (as you can see in the photos) a bit transfer-prone. It applied nicely, evenly, and cleanly. It didn’t dry as quickly as other waterproof mascaras. I’m not sure why, but I haven’t seen this with other CoverGirl mascaras. Once it did cure, I got all-day wear with no flaking or smudging.